Claim Reporting Toll Free Phone Numbers In the event of a claim, contact your insurance carrier as soon as possible. Listed below are the direct reporting claim phone numbers for the companies we represent. When you call to report the claim, make sure you have your policy number available. Central Mutual - 888/263-2924 Central Mutual (after hours) - 800/241-2541 Erie - 800/533-3982 Aegis Security - 800/233-2160 American Modern - 800/543-2644 American Reliable - 800/535-1333 Builders Mutual - 800/809-4862 Foremost - 800/527-3907 GMAC - 800/468-3466 Key Risk - 800/883-9568 Ohio Casualty - 800/366-6446 Viking - 800/672-4773 Progressive - 800/274-4499 Zurich - 800/239-6851